What's wrong with -90deg phase lag?

Shreesh P. Mysore, Nov 18 2002

Note: If the phase is -90deg, we refer to it as a 90 deg phase lag. So it doesnt make sense to say a "phase lag of -90deg" unless one purposely wishes to say "phase lead of 90deg" using two negatives (not recommended).

[Here is the answer assuming that the question relates to the 90 deg phase lag in PI controllers. Please send me email if this is not what you meant to ask.]

An integral control action is of the form Ki/s. This means that the contribution of this term to the magnitude of the open loop transfer function is Ki/|jw| =Ki/|w|. Thus for low frequencies, the integral action results in a large gain and helps to eliminate offset (or steady state error) by beating down any disturbances. Integral action is therefore desirable to combat steady state error. Now, the integral action also has a phase component of -90deg. So if the original system did not have any integrators (i.e., no 1/s terms), then at low frequencies, the original transfer function has a phase of 0deg. But the introduction of the integral action has now introduced a phase of -90deg at low frequencies (in general, it introduces a phase lag of 90deg at low frequencies). Thus the price we pay for eliminating steady state error by introducing an integral action is the additional phase lag of 90deg. A similar reasoning (look at the magnitude and phase of Kp + Ki/(jw) as w->0) yields the same conclusions (at low frequencies) for PI controller.
The reason why addition of phase lag (at low frequencies) is not a good thing is that it can reduce the phase margin of the system: pm=180+phi, where phi is the phase of the open loop transfer function when its magnitude=1. So if phi was initially -100 and then becomes say -160, then the pm has reduced from 80deg to 20deg, making the system less robust. An addition of a -90 phase at low frequencies has exactly this effect of reducing phi (typically by an amount less than 90deg). In fact, for the Caltech ducted fan example, it turns out that the phase margin becomes negative (!) when a PI controller is used. [The instability caused by the integral action can be combated using a derivative action - hence the use of PID controllers].